- Posts: 1130
- Thank you received: 7
Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.
Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.
I thought that particular strawman had been exposed for what it was already, an entirely invalid argument. We'll start with the fact that you only have to purchase auto insurance if you own a car and you drive the car on a public road. You can own a vehicle and drive it on your private property without purchasing either insurance or registering that vehicle with the State. We'll also note that you are not compelled to purchase automobile insurance to operate a bike on the public roads or in order to ride public transportation. Your failure to purchase automobile insurance if you don't own a car, or if you ride a bike instead of inside a car, doesn't subject you to being taxed by the federal government for your failure to purchase a car and insurance either.archer wrote: Why is the mandate such an issue for health insurance but auto insurance is not?
Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.
Indeed they have. And why is that? Might it be because of another federal mandate foisted on the States that required an emergency room to treat people with no insurance when they had the sniffles? Would those people be using emergency rooms for routine care in the absence of that prior federal mandate?archer wrote: The subject is, and was, health insurance. And don't act like people haven't been using emergency rooms for their routine health care needs costing us all higher premiums and health care costs.
Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.
Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.
Automobile insurance is mandated by the state, not the federal, government and not all states require it. New Hampshire comes to mind.PrintSmith wrote:
I thought that particular strawman had been exposed for what it was already, an entirely invalid argument. We'll start with the fact that you only have to purchase auto insurance if you own a car and you drive the car on a public road. You can own a vehicle and drive it on your private property without purchasing either insurance or registering that vehicle with the State. We'll also note that you are not compelled to purchase automobile insurance to operate a bike on the public roads or in order to ride public transportation. Your failure to purchase automobile insurance if you don't own a car, or if you ride a bike instead of inside a car, doesn't subject you to being taxed by the federal government for your failure to purchase a car and insurance either.archer wrote: Why is the mandate such an issue for health insurance but auto insurance is not?
There are two instances where your argument is invalid, only one is necessary to demonstrate the fallacy of the argument.
Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.
Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.
Mary Scott wrote:
Automobile insurance is mandated by the state, not the federal, government and not all states require it. New Hampshire comes to mind.PrintSmith wrote:
I thought that particular strawman had been exposed for what it was already, an entirely invalid argument. We'll start with the fact that you only have to purchase auto insurance if you own a car and you drive the car on a public road. You can own a vehicle and drive it on your private property without purchasing either insurance or registering that vehicle with the State. We'll also note that you are not compelled to purchase automobile insurance to operate a bike on the public roads or in order to ride public transportation. Your failure to purchase automobile insurance if you don't own a car, or if you ride a bike instead of inside a car, doesn't subject you to being taxed by the federal government for your failure to purchase a car and insurance either.archer wrote: Why is the mandate such an issue for health insurance but auto insurance is not?
There are two instances where your argument is invalid, only one is necessary to demonstrate the fallacy of the argument.
Unlike almost every other state, New Hampshire does not automatically require motorists to carry an auto liability insurance policy or provide some of financial backing in order to drive a vehicle within its boundaries.
http://www.dmv.org/nh-new-hampshire/car-insurance.php
Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.
Hippie Love Fest wrote: Archer, just out of curiosity, how do you feel about this?
In your opinion, does this elevate women? Is this really what feminists of days gone by truly fought for? Do you believe casual sex is a government entitlement?
Just wondering...
Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.
Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.