I hope everyone is enjoying this beautiful chilly day!
I wanted to take a quick moment to talk with you all about professionalism as it pertains to forestry and wildfire mitigation. Frankly, there have been a lot of concerning posts, advertisements, comments, and discussions across social media platforms regarding forestry, tree work, and particularly wildfire prevention over the last few weeks.
I’m not here to put any person or company down, or to sound overly preachy, but I believe the time has come for our community to discuss what you should reasonably expect as a consumer of forestry services. This is especially important as we move into Wildfire Prevention Month tomorrow, when you’ll undoubtedly be flooded with ads from a glut of new companies offering their services.
I’ll do my best to keep this brief—but I’m the son of a preacher, so no promises.
First, let me say this clearly: there is a contractor for everyone, depending on work scope, project scale, affordability, and your personal tolerance for risk. There is room for all kinds of contractors to help us achieve the collective goals of community wildfire resilience and forest health.
However, the points below are really just a baseline of what should be considered acceptable.
Property Lines Matter
No matter what an insurance company may say, please respect property boundaries and your neighbors. Timber Law is very clear, and you do not have any right to do work or force work on someone else’s property without their permission. That said, forestry can also be an incredible opportunity to join hands with neighboring landowners and work together.
Some of the most impactful projects we’ve completed at Forestwerx have been when multiple landowners collaborate across property lines to collectively improve their environment. As we all know, wildfire, beetles, and environmental impacts do not respect invisible lines on the ground—even though we should.
PPE matters
Any person—contractor or otherwise—should be wearing full PPE when performing biomass reduction work.
Every six days, someone dies in a logging accident. It is one of the most dangerous professions in the United States. Helmet, eye protection, gloves, hearing protection, and chainsaw chaps should be considered the bare minimum.
I truly cannot believe how many ads we’ve seen lately featuring contractors promoting services without even basic PPE. As someone who also responds when things go wrong, I personally beg you: Please Wear PPE!
Insurance matters
Please verify your contractor’s insurance coverage: liability, inland marine, workers’ compensation, commercial auto, etc.
If you don’t, you may be directly at risk if something happens on your property. Imagine a serious accident occurring on your project and the contractor has no coverage. Do you want to be exposed to that liability?
Honesty in capability matters
We’ve encountered quite a few landowners receiving outlandish quotes from new companies that simply do not have the capability to perform the jobs they are bidding—or at least not perform them well.
If you have a large, complicated forestry project or a technical climbing job, ask your contractor for photographs, references, and examples of previous work of a similar nature. Sometimes you may even be able to visit an active project.
Every year we are called in to fix “low-cost” work done by companies that were never qualified to do it in the first place. It often ends up costing the landowner double—or more—than it would have cost to do it right the first time.
If you’re a new contractor, please be realistic about your capabilities and honest with your clients. Referring a project to another company better suited for the work is not a knock on you—it is professionalism at its best.
Honesty in experience matters
As mentioned above, there is room for everyone here—from the new contractor operating out of a pickup truck with a chainsaw, insurance, training, and proper PPE, to some of the largest logging companies in the world.
However, particularly in wildfire mitigation, we are seeing an onslaught of people claiming “expertise” where it is not appropriate.
Would you hire a plumber who had never seen water to design your home’s plumbing system? Probably not.
The same logic applies to wildland fire behavior modification.
Along those same lines, calling yourself a firefighter when you are not one is similar to calling yourself a veteran if you never served. It’s not acceptable.
There are certifications that provide useful baseline knowledge of wildland fire, and they absolutely have value—but many were originally intended to complement years of actual fireline experience. Certifications alone do not make someone an expert.
There are multiple contractors in our area who truly do have both the depth of experience and the certifications to expertly guide you through wildfire mitigation, forestry management, and home hardening. That experience is something that should be discussed up front.
Thankfully, we also have incredible resources in our mountain-area fire departments’ mitigation divisions that can help guide decision-making on your projects. Their expertise can make it entirely appropriate for contractors without direct fire experience to execute the work—but that professional guidance should be part of the process.
False affiliations matter
There is no such thing as a company “with,” “for,” “trained by,” or “preferred by” (insert fire department name here). Full stop.
This is false advertising and, frankly, an inappropriate exploitation of the fire district's public trust.
Fire districts may maintain a list of contractors who have completed a very basic orientation of their expectations, and some companies may even work alongside them on projects. They may even provide a list of these contractors to people when they are doing defensible space and home hardening inspections But these are public entities—they do not publicly endorse private companies.
Final thoughts
I know that was a long post, but I feel like at this juncture we needed a community check-in.
I’m sure some will disagree, but hopefully this is helpful as we move into what is shaping up to be a particularly dangerous wildfire season.
Thank you for entertaining my musings and stay safe,
Kyle from Forestwerx
Pic: Almost 100 combined years of fire and forestry experience creating a shaded fuel break to help protect the Lookout Mountain community.