Amy Coney Barrett, 5:30 PM Tonight

"What respect is left in a court that has been packed with underqualified judges appointed by McDonald? "

Please elucidate the reasons for stating that Justice Amy Coney Barrett is underqualified?

koobookie wrote:

FredHayek wrote: It is tradition to celebrate an appointment to the White House. Obama celebrated Elena Kagan's appointment.

Oh, but Fred, this was so much different that when Obama celebrated with his appointees. This was theatrics on a grand scale, worthy of McDonald's reality star status.

Do you have anything to say on the idiotic Kavanaugh comments?

[/b]

U have to consider the COMPLETE character of K. and when U do,the comment is NO surprise.

I am ATTEMPTING to give this new judge a neutral position...altho,FIRST out of the gate was a request
for her to recuse her self from the election decision.....THAT and her view on R V W decided correctly.
We already known K.'s opinion and with the new appointee being HIGHLY religious oriented, it will
be interesting IF she considers the law CORRECTLY decided....I have other concerns,but will WAIT
AND WATCH....if she can be impartial and fair as she has stated in her interviews....

ramage wrote: "What respect is left in a court that has been packed with underqualified judges appointed by McDonald? "

Please elucidate the reasons for stating that Justice Amy Coney Barrett is underqualified?

Served only three years on Seventh Circuit as a judge.

Compare to Merrick Garland, who has served on the U.S. Court of Appeals for the District of Columbia since 1997, which is 20 more years of judicial experience than Barrett.

Kagan never served on a Court of Appeals. As a matter of fact was never a judge on any court.

More to the point is that Barrett's only under-qualification in your opinion?

ramage wrote: Kagan never served on a Court of Appeals. As a matter of fact was never a judge on any court.

More to the point is that Barrett's only under-qualification in your opinion?

Do you think that three years on the bench makes her qualified to serve as a Supreme Court justice?

Yes

Do you think that Kagan's lack of any judicial experience should disqualify her from serving on the Supreme Court?

ramage wrote: Do you think that Kagan's lack of any judicial experience should disqualify her from serving on the Supreme Court?

Kagan is definitely one of the underperformers on the current court.

Let's make this simple, Kooobookie, what are the necessary qualifications for a Justice of the U.S. Supreme Court, in your opinion.

ramage wrote: Let's make this simple, Kooobookie, what are the necessary qualifications for a Justice of the U.S. Supreme Court, in your opinion.

You already had checkmate when you asked her about Kagan's experience.