The Decline Of Civility?

27 Jun 2012 11:37 #31 by CC
Replied by CC on topic The Decline Of Civility?

PrintSmith wrote: Speaking only for myself, I respond in a manner with which the poster themselves seems most comfortable. It is polite, and possibly also advantageous, to abide by the customs of the person who originates the thread or when responding directly to a comment on the subject made by another poster. One should try to speak in the same manner and language that the person they are dealing with is most comfortable when striving for clarity in the conversation. When one is in a diplomatic situation one uses the language of diplomacy, but when dealing with a street urchin one uses the language of the street.


LOL...Fair enough.

I will also defend myself vigorously when I am personally attacked.
I will defend my beliefs.
What has bothered me so much lately is the level of personal attacks and baiting that seems to be directed at certain individuals.
In some cases....this has gone on for years and has grown incredibly tiresome.

Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.

27 Jun 2012 11:47 #32 by 2wlady
Replied by 2wlady on topic The Decline Of Civility?
Becky, I didn't mean to imply that everyone who initially came here was uncivil or kicked out of pinecam. I just meant that SOME of the folks wanted to blow steam in an uncivil manner and 285bound let them do it.

Hope this doesn't sound judgmental because it is not meant that way.

Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.

27 Jun 2012 12:17 #33 by JMC
Replied by JMC on topic The Decline Of Civility?
My last word on this thread, we as a community needed a free outlet, the authoritarians from PC made a joke of a "Community Web Site", Now it seems other authoritarians want their model to shut other people up.
One form of censorship should not be replaced by another.IMHO
We are grown up and if you don't want to participate don't. This site was not a better Pinecam but the anti-Pinecam.
The ring was for name calling, insults, profanity and free form speech. Courthouse was for civil, polite discussion of current events.
I agree the moderation has not separated the 2 as well as envisioned.
Lighten up and appreciate that you have a place to insult and be insulted.
What a bunch of phony wimps.

Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.

27 Jun 2012 12:39 #34 by LOL
Replied by LOL on topic The Decline Of Civility?

jmc wrote: My last word on this thread.....What a bunch of phony wimps.


Wanna bet? :lol:

I'll take the insults and snarky posts over excessive moderation anyday. Nothin is perfect.

If you want to be, press one. If you want not to be, press 2

Republicans are red, democrats are blue, neither of them, gives a flip about you.

Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.

27 Jun 2012 12:50 #35 by CC
Replied by CC on topic The Decline Of Civility?
2wlady....I didn't take it that way.
I just wanted to clear that many many people who were dismissed by PC were treated that way unfairly.

Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.

27 Jun 2012 13:22 #36 by CC
Replied by CC on topic The Decline Of Civility?

jmc wrote: My last word on this thread, we as a community needed a free outlet, the authoritarians from PC made a joke of a "Community Web Site", Now it seems other authoritarians want their model to shut other people up.
One form of censorship should not be replaced by another.IMHO
We are grown up and if you don't want to participate don't. This site was not a better Pinecam but the anti-Pinecam.
The ring was for name calling, insults, profanity and free form speech. Courthouse was for civil, polite discussion of current events.
I agree the moderation has not separated the 2 as well as envisioned.
Lighten up and appreciate that you have a place to insult and be insulted.
What a bunch of phony wimps.


JMC... I agree with you.
Had the posts been placed where they belonged.....it would be one thing.
The entire site has now become the ring and that is a sad state of affairs.

Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.

27 Jun 2012 14:43 #37 by Mtn Gramma
Replied by Mtn Gramma on topic The Decline Of Civility?

Becky wrote:

jmc wrote: My last word on this thread, we as a community needed a free outlet, the authoritarians from PC made a joke of a "Community Web Site", Now it seems other authoritarians want their model to shut other people up.
One form of censorship should not be replaced by another.IMHO
We are grown up and if you don't want to participate don't. This site was not a better Pinecam but the anti-Pinecam.
The ring was for name calling, insults, profanity and free form speech. Courthouse was for civil, polite discussion of current events.
I agree the moderation has not separated the 2 as well as envisioned.
Lighten up and appreciate that you have a place to insult and be insulted.
What a bunch of phony wimps.


JMC... I agree with you.
Had the posts been placed where they belonged.....it would be one thing.
The entire site has now become the ring and that is a sad state of affairs.


Wow -- I sure didn't get that from JMC's post. JMC, did I misunderstand you, and Becky's interpretation is really what you meant?

Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.

27 Jun 2012 15:18 #38 by CC
Replied by CC on topic The Decline Of Civility?
Let me be clear. i am not for censoring any post here.
I am in favor of hateful abusive posts being moved to the ring.
That was the original intent of the ring.
That sort of moderation has not existed on this site for quite some time.

The ring was for name calling, insults, profanity and free form speech. Courthouse was for civil, polite discussion of current events.
I agree the moderation has not separated the 2 as well as envisioned.


Did I misunderstand your meaning JMC?

Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.

28 Jun 2012 17:03 #39 by ScienceChic
Sorry if this is bringing up a dead subject, I wanted to take some time to carefully consider/sleep on an answer before posting. This isn't quite the best answer that I'd like to give, but I have to leave for the Combined Chamber Mixer now and don't want to leave this any longer than I already have. I've had doctor's appointments for my son, or meetings scheduled pretty much constantly until 8pm yesterday, and starting back up again at 9:30am today so I just haven't had a chance to get back to this before now. I understand that addressing the issues brought up probably won't change a thing, but I don't want to leave them unaddressed either. I want to explain my side just so you all know where I'm coming from.

Becky wrote: The above removed posts by myself are evidence that very little time is spent in actual reading or moderation of this site.

I saw your post, but decided to give you a minute to fix it yourself, rather than jumping on top of it immediately. Some people get sensitive when moderation is done at the first second possible, rather than letting the poster take a minute to correct it themselves. My apologies for not taking care of your duplicate posts immediately, I didn't think they were that huge a problem and didn't realize that they would get used as evidence against how this site is run. As to this "entire site turning into the Ring", perhaps you could report some posts in any of the other forums that you think should be moved? There was a whole thread just moved from the CF to The Ring on the 19th (as soon as I could do it because I'd just spent that day and the previous one driving 20 hours, my apologies for not being right on top of it), yet you and that same poster kept going at it in the CF in yet another thread, and were even called out on it in that thread - you say you prefer personal responsibility and people should be self-moderating, then you say we should be moving them for you - which is it? Somehow I don't think that anything will ever be done to your satisfaction Becky, because it won't be run the way you would do it at that moment in time. JMC said that it hasn't been done "as well as envisioned", that's certainly not "That sort of moderation has not existed on this site for quite some time." as you put it.
So big picture: is the entire site going to hell, or do you just not like the few threads that you participate in? Do you read everything here and get a feel for the percentage that gets moved/edited versus left alone, or is your perception biased by the few threads you read/participate in? I ask because a small sample of threads aren't really representative if not looked at in the context of all of the threads posted in a set time frame. And yes, I do read all of the threads, maybe not as they are posted, but they do all get read.

Becky wrote: I like this site....I want it to do well but I am worried that it is moving to a pretty ugly place and no one is really watching the store.

Last week you accused me of not spending enough time up in the community, now after I subtly point out that I'm spending a ton of time up there, suddenly I'm not spending enough time watching the site - I'm damned if I do, and damned if I don't? I appreciate that it means that much to you that you worry about this site, keep posting here, hope it does well, and are concerned that there isn't enough volunteer help. How about helping again and being a part of the solution? Because when you and the other scanners quit, I had to take on yet another duty that I really didn't have time for. It's pretty much impossible to listen to a scanner when attending a meeting that I'm videotaping, or when I take my kids to taekwondo or swimming lessons. I've got a 9 year old and a 4 year old who I'd like to spend time with this summer (and who get on me for being on the computer too much as it is) - they're only young once. I'm coordinating an event, the Barefoot, Bluegrass, and BBQ Festival, that will hopefully bring some exposure and support to this community through tourism, and also benefit a very worthy nonprofit whose work makes the troubles people have here on 285Bound look like trifles (unless being kidnapped or sold and forced as a child or teenager to prostitute yourself 10-15 times a day or be beaten so severely that you lose an eye isn't as bad as not having a mean, nasty post moved to another forum?), and I'm chairing the Conifer and Platte Canyon Chambers of Commerce's 285 Tourism Committee, after helping to create the Foothills Adventure Map over the past 8 months, in another attempt to help this community by increasing tourism dollars spent here. Last week when I went out of town for my 20 year high school reunion, it was the first week in 11 months that I haven't worked a 90 hour week (I've pulled more all-nighters in the last 6 months than I did in my entire college career), and yes, oftentimes I am the only one around to moderate. I could dearly use some more help because I can't possibly be everywhere all at once. What would you propose as a solution?

And let me say this now, I'm not saying all of this to get sympathy, or to make myself sound good, because I am not all that and a bag of chips, and no one forced me to do all the above - I just refuse to give anything less than my best and I'm letting you know the lengths that I already go to in order to provide a better product and service with my business. I am acutely aware that it's not enough at times. Everyone I talk to seems to be extremely busy these days taking on extra responsibilities, so it's not just me. I appreciate that you all let me know that there's not enough being done, and I agree to a point, but I'm going to ask for some perspective and say that now's the time to put up - to be blunt, help by moderating yourselves, or volunteering. One other way you can help is to go to https://www.missionsmallbusiness.com/ and vote for 285Bound.com - if I can afford to hire some help, that will take care of some of these issues. Right now, I'm not even breaking even so there's no way I can afford anyone, and the awesome volunteers already helping 285Bound are swamped with their own businesses and lives too.

Becky wrote: There are a boat load of bully's here who need a good talking to behind the scenes.

And who says that isn't happening? You have no clue how I even spend my day apparently, so what makes you think there is NO moderation going on. I've tried to approach moderating in a minimal way, dealing with things behind the scenes, and let the posters police themselves and each other, as was done by the previous owners. I'll be the first to admit I could use a lot more help, but if you want to be part of the solution, how about posting scanner information on the site again so it frees me up from trying to listen to the scanner on top of everything else that I do? Or volunteering in some other way?

Becky wrote: ( I do disagree that there have been times when ownership or past admins have been guilty of careful personal attacks that set a tone for others here.)

Can you please show me when I've attacked you? I've defended myself from your attacks, I've explained my side of the story, and just because you don't agree (because your POV isn't the only side of the story or the truth of the situation), doesn't make it an attack. I've never called you names, and I still take your phone calls and speak to you civilly and politely. The moderating isn't "unfair" if you expect that you will get back what you give - that's your personal responsibility isn't it? If you don't like how others post to you, then take a look at how you post toward them - you yourself admit that you will "vigorously defend yourself from an attack", and that you "give ***** a little taste of their own medicine", so you know full well what you are saying and where, you choose to post what you do and where. I have never encouraged anyone to "attack" you, nor have I harassed you or subjected you to any moderation that everyone else isn't also subject to.
Despite the fact that you've posted outright that you have no respect for me, I still listen to your opinions and weigh them as to whether if I take your suggestions/complaints about the site that it will make the site better. So if you want to actually step up and do something to help, great. If not, fine, but don't expect these same issues to continue to be dealt with by me - I've got other things to get done to provide a better product and service to this community. If anyone is interested in volunteering, PM me - I'll find a way to use and abuse you. :wink: Like I said before, I still think this site is the bomb and the members rock. Civility comes and goes as events pull us together, and the environment and life circumstances wear on us.

"Now, more than ever, the illusions of division threaten our very existence. We all know the truth: more connects us than separates us. But in times of crisis the wise build bridges, while the foolish build barriers. We must find a way to look after one another as if we were one single tribe.” -King T'Challa, Black Panther

The truth is incontrovertible. Malice may attack it. ignorance may deride it, but in the end, there it is. ~Winston Churchill

Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.

28 Jun 2012 21:44 #40 by CC
Replied by CC on topic The Decline Of Civility?
I didn't fix the triple posting because I did not know it had occurred until the next morning.
By then...there were other posts and I could not delete the triplicates.
It wasn't my technical glitch and not my site to moderate.

I am sorry that you have such a busy life. It sounds a lot like everyone else's here on this site.

I would tell you about how I spend my day but it is really not the point.
You made a choice to buy this website and you are free to run it as you please...
Mine as well as others observations are no less valid both publicly or privately.
The triplicate post and what may have caused it aren't really a big deal in the grand scheme of things but they were an easy example of how things are missed here pretty regularly.

I notice that JMC made a similar observation yet he was not taken to task in a half page thesis on his opinionated bad behavior.

This is YOUR website. You are free to run it as you please. Please remember though that the foundations of this website were free speech. That means I am entitled to voice my opinion and you are entitled to disagree.
I have made the comments here because I do care about the philosophy that this website was started with.
It is my OPINION that the website is being hurt by a lack of appropriate attention and moderation. It is merely my opinion but I have it on good authority that I am in very good company.

I have watched as this community has gone into a crisis mode twice this summer and yet the heavy lifting is left to others while you attend Chamber Mixers or vacation.

Many people living here are afraid to go on vacation.

You can bust my chops all you want SC but you and I are aware of a little deeper understanding of many issues and how we have gotten to this point. You will even have a few folks who dislike me enough to come to your aid. Some might even share your point of view.
But I can tell you this.....you are just as good at confusing the real issues as you say I am.
You manipulate facts to meet your needs as well as anyone I have ever seen.
A good example of your twisting information you gave yourself.
You failed to take any real responsibility for the TSAC debacle and actually threw a person who has worked hard to help you under a bus after bringing the new turn of events as a result of an add in the Chamber Directory to their attention. You claimed you didn't know how to contact the person who could help with troop support at the VFW.
You had met with the woman in question....she was a VFW breakfast away from contact.
Your members here remind me of that saying....."You should dance with them that brung ya."
I don't know how many of your members attend Chamber Mixers but I do know that a boat load of your members here can be found at a VFW Breakfast once a month supporting son's and daughters in this community who are risking their lives to keep us safe.
You made this personal a while back for me and I will admit that it has remained personal.
There has been some deception going on behind the scenes and I am uncomfortable with it.
People have been hurt by misrepresentations and I am angry about it.
Contrary to what a handful of folks believe....I don't start crap here but I will be the first to admit that I won't run from it when it comes my way.
I have plenty of negative traits but the one negative trait I do not possess is the ability to lie.
I will be the first to admit that perhaps my approach should be a bit more diplomatic but truth be told.....I would rather just cut right to the chase and save the time.

now after I subtly point out that I'm spending a ton of time up there,


Are you serious......I am still trying to find the subtle amidst all the excuses.

I don't enjoy the excuse luxury in my line of work.
If I perform at less than my best....people are let down.

We all have our burdens to carry. When the burden gets to great....you delegate some of the work load to a qualified person to help you.

Many people up here drive 3 hours a day just to earn a living. They try to advertise on your website yet they aren't given much support here by the management.

I wouldn't waste my time complaining here if I didn't care about this site or the concept it represented at one time.
I have tried to voice these issues privately but the conversation has fallen on deaf ears.
I am unusual in the respect that I will speak up. Most will just go away quietly.

We all have families, jobs, children, grandchildren, and a ton of responsibility. We spend hours a day away from our families.
Most of us don't enjoy the luxury of "subtle" excuse as to why we don't do our job.

It's great that you are an active member of the Chamber.
I am happy that you have made a commitment to those who are sold into prostitution 10-15 times a day.
I hope that the Bluegrass BBQ is a success........but in the mean time.....people here are afraid to go to work and leave their homes. Our cherished belongings are packed in boxes by the door and our hearts are broken for our neighbors who have lost so much. (I realize that those problems pale in comparison to the causes you have made a commitment to.)

Your right, you have chosen to commit to SO MANY things.
You also made a commitment to 1839 members to do a good job here and by your own admission, you are not.
So you can take me to task about personal responsibility but how about you taking on a little yourself.

Excuses are like @ssholes..........

As for helping 285bound out....I was made a cost benefit statistic a while back so I choose to serve my community where I have ALWAYS served my community. I am helping....just not here. My trust was breached and the bell cannot be unrung.
My focus is this community. I can make a change here. I know what my limitations are.

One good thesis deserves another.

(The canary story still applies)

Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.

Time to create page: 0.172 seconds
Powered by Kunena Forum
sponsors
© My Mountain Town (new)
Google+