My perspective: Time to look at ourselves

16 Nov 2011 10:59 #31 by ScienceChic

The Liberals GOP Twin wrote: Right... our politicians are certainly not a total failure. Our politicians on both sides of the aisle are a complete success. They have successfully robbed us blind, ingratiated themselves with power and money and have established a political class that is in no way working for any of us. The real 1% are the politicians, all politicians, federal, state and local and their special interest and corporate cronies. The real 99% are the rest of us. The Occupy Movement should shut down the silly camps all over the country and converge on Washington. That's what should be occupied... Washington DC. Go to the source.

But that won't happen because we are divided and we shall waste our time and chase partisan phantoms as we work as deflectors for the political class, taking focus off the real problems.

You've been fooled into believing that voting the "right people" into office will solve the problems. My opinion... anyone running for office, local, state or federal will eventually be of use to the Political Class. For the few that don't already have ulterior motives, or for those that get into office and don't "play the game," those will not be of any real effect in their particular position.

We are not the government any longer. We are given the illusion that we can make a difference... but there is no difference. "Read my lips... no new taxes" to "hope and change" have not accomplished anything. We slip deeper and deeper into a debt based society, under the thumb of politicians, special interest and big money... otherwise know as the Political Class. There is a 99%, but they are not only the poor or middle class. The 99% are all the citizens who are not directly part of the Political Class... it doesn't matter if you are rich or poor, hard working or lazy... there should be no divide between the 99%... the 1% are not Wall Street, they are not the rich... they are the plutocrats and kleptocrats and their crony sidekicks.

Voting right or left is not the answer, it's broke and we need a "clean sweep," wash the whole thing out and disinfect. Rinse and repeat when necessary.

No, the politicians are only part of the 1%. George Carlin put it perfectly in the video that CV posted here and the Occupy movement is doing it right - they have focused on the root problem - greed - and how it has corrupted our politics. See this article for a recount of the history of what's happened to get us to where we are today. OWS protestors aren't just focusing on Wall St, but the politicians too, and you'd see that if you read what they've actually wrote, rather than media regurgitations and biased representations of them. Are there idiotic, fringe lunatic, and/or criminals who a part of it? Yes, the same rough percentage as any other grouping of people. Are there clueless morons who can't connect that they are there protesting to make their country better at the same time that they are disrespecting the very symbol of that country? Yes. But the corruption is widespread, and widespread the movement must be - it's not just Washington, it's everywhere. Chickaree is right - we are the government (see my sig line) and this movement is the attempt to take it back; to stop being so apathetic. If you want our downfall to stop, then I'd recommend joining them, rather than dissing them, for at least they are trying to make a change.

BearMtnHIB wrote: Sorry I have to pick on a posters sig line here - but the above quote is just dead wrong. Government has indeed become our enemy and it no longer serves the citizen- it has become corrupted and the choices it makes are no longer our choices. We can not find common ground. It has become our caretaker with ever expanding laws, rules, regulations and taxes.

We can not get back to prosperity by voting for Pelosi, or Reid, or Romney. Government has to match it's size with the money it gets now- or with even less money than it gets now and that's the only way. It has to give up the notion that it is our caretaker- we are capable of taking responsibility for ourselves and can take care of ourselves.

Our ideology does matter- the people we vote for does matter. If we elect the proper leaders - the problem of massive government can be addressed. We can not allow the "government is the answer" ideology to prevail or nothing will ever change- in fact it will get worse. If you like the direction that the economy and the country are heading- keep it up- keep voting for the same corrupt ideology, but if you want things to get better, we all better accept the fact that we must abandon this path to a socialist welfare state.

We do need to look at ourselves and do what is best for America- not what we think we are entitled to FROM government.

The line at the end "We've got to retrieve our citizenship" is exactly how I interpret it to mean exactly what you just said above BearMtn. Ideology isn't going to change the corruption because it's pervasive on both sides of the aisle. Retrieving our citizenship means getting more actively involved, becoming more informed, less apathetic, and taking more responsibility for ourselves and for our government.

Do we need more personal responsibility? Absolutely. Fiscal responsibility? Definitely. But we also need more fairness in legislation and taxation, and accountability in our representatives as well, to make the complete change required to get us back on top.

Rockdoc, I'm glad you clarified that you don't think that the 99% are necessarily lazy, just feel entitled. Yes, there certainly is a pervasive consciousness that the government should provide X, Y, and Z for us - some of this came about at the request of the people, some by special interests who have slowly maneuvered us into believing that must be the case when it shouldn't necessarily be so, but that's something that I see people waking up to and changing their habits on (yes, some are still stubbornly refusing to see that we will all have to make sacrifices, and cuts to even our favorite programs will be required, but I see that attitude shifting). Our economy is still in the tank b/c Americans aren't spending...why? They're paying off debt, or losing their jobs and going bankrupt. The consciousness that we can load up on debt for material possessions is shifting - I noticed the other day that I rarely see temp tags in vehicles these days, when last year at this time I couldn't throw a rock out my car window at a stop light and not hit one, they were everywhere. The biggest problem, and what the Occupy Movement is mainly protesting, is the inequality - that no matter how hard the average middle-class or poor American works these days, that it still doesn't make a difference because the deck is stacked against us. As put in this video , higher GDP does not equate to more wealth for the 99%.

Are the people who signed the toxic interest-only loans responsible/at fault for making such a dumb choice? Sure are, they should've known better or asked more questions. But why were loans like pushed at people who were more likely to default and get us all into this mess? And why are those people still not held accountable for their actions? Those who signed, and lost their homes as a result, have paid their price - now what about the people sitting on the other side of that table? Just like Lindsay Lohan, the privileged have been held to no accountability. Profits for some corporations are still up, and CEOs are getting fat bonuses at the same time that they are laying off workers, or moving more jobs overseas - that doesn't help the economy, only those few at the top. That is what must change.

"Now, more than ever, the illusions of division threaten our very existence. We all know the truth: more connects us than separates us. But in times of crisis the wise build bridges, while the foolish build barriers. We must find a way to look after one another as if we were one single tribe.” -King T'Challa, Black Panther

The truth is incontrovertible. Malice may attack it. ignorance may deride it, but in the end, there it is. ~Winston Churchill

Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.

16 Nov 2011 11:05 #32 by FredHayek

AspenValley wrote: I'm just sitting here scratching my head over how the "1%" went from being the "idle rich" and the "leisure class" to the only people with a work ethic in the minds of some?

Also wondering how anyone thinks the rich could be getting richer since their profits depend on the work of those lazy, entitled bums known as the 99%?

Ayn Rand was a poisonous writer, but I wasn't aware that the entire water supply of the United States of America has been dosed with it. Yet it's almost the only explanation.


I always think the "idle rich" was overstated. Even back in the robber baron days, most of the guys making money came from poor backgrounds. Carnegie? Started out as a poor immigrant.

It is nice to think that the 1% are all trust funders who just collect dividend checks but I bet most of them have made their own money or built on the money of their parents like John Huntsman and Mitt Romney.

Thomas Sowell: There are no solutions, just trade-offs.

Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.

16 Nov 2011 11:19 #33 by Rockdoc

AspenValley wrote: I'm just sitting here scratching my head over how the "1%" went from being the "idle rich" and the "leisure class" to the only people with a work ethic in the minds of some?

Also wondering how anyone thinks the rich could be getting richer since their profits depend on the work of those lazy, entitled bums known as the 99%?

Ayn Rand was a poisonous writer, but I wasn't aware that the entire water supply of the United States of America has been dosed with it. Yet it's almost the only explanation.


Nice to see you engaging AV. Your first sentence is puzzling. Who on here is the 1%? Let's face it, the 1% not only worked hard, but also had some luck go along with their vision. Now, mind you, my perception of the 1% is the millionaires and on up.

Your brush strokes are broader than my own in sentence two. My original intent was focus on what I keep hearing about the 99% being enslaved by the 1%, something I think is utter rubbish. I've also gotten the perception that many think it impossible to move up in class. I say bunk to that as well with a qualifier. You are not going to make it just working a normal work week or remaining static in your skill sets. It takes enormous extra effort to overcome the entropy associated with each class level.

If your post was directed at me, then be aware I do not even know who Ayn Rand is, nor do I care. One has to be totally blind not to see the evolution of entitlement feeling in our society. The opinions expressed by me are my own. I'm always up for enlightenment.

Along with entitlement goes a readiness to blame others for our own failures and there is a general mindset that supports such a perspective. McDonalds coffee comes to mind as a blatant example.

Just because I see things this way does not imply equally valid view points and approaches different from mine don't exist. I do think we as a people need to look at ourselves again. It is high time.

Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.

16 Nov 2011 11:29 #34 by chickaree
The message I get from the OWS movement (disclosure: daughter and SIL are active participants AND employed) is that they object to a small percentage controlling the direction of our country-government and economy both. I can't argue with that. They are outraged that the very people who caused our economic crisis continue to benefit from it. I can't argue with that either. I also believe that if you want to make a difference you need to get out there and make it. For that reason I tend to admire everyone who actively protests whether I agree with their message or not.

Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.

16 Nov 2011 11:37 #35 by FredHayek

chickaree wrote: The message I get from the OWS movement (disclosure: daughter and SIL are active participants AND employed) is that they object to a small percentage controlling the direction of our country-government and economy both. I can't argue with that. They are outraged that the very people who caused our economic crisis continue to benefit from it. I can't argue with that either. I also believe that if you want to make a difference you need to get out there and make it. For that reason I tend to admire everyone who actively protests whether I agree with their message or not.


Like I have said before, I am sympathetic to the OWS crowd, but they really are doing it the wrong way. Hanging out in a park smoking dope and beating drums won't change anything. Run for political office, or work for the candidates you support. Working within the system will do a lot more good than pouting in your tents.

Thomas Sowell: There are no solutions, just trade-offs.

Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.

16 Nov 2011 11:45 #36 by Rockdoc

Science Chic wrote: <snip>
Are the people who signed the toxic interest-only loans responsible/at fault for making such a dumb choice? Sure are, they should've known better or asked more questions. But why were loans like pushed at people who were more likely to default and get us all into this mess? And why are those people still not held accountable for their actions? Those who signed, and lost their homes as a result, have paid their price - now what about the people sitting on the other side of that table? Just like Lindsay Lohan, the privileged have been held to no accountability. Profits for some corporations are still up, and CEOs are getting fat bonuses at the same time that they are laying off workers, or moving more jobs overseas - that doesn't help the economy, only those few at the top. That is what must change.


It's my perspective that we really do need to take more responsibility for our actions. Companies, Banks, etc. provide products for us to buy. I do not see those loans being pushed on people, rather I see people electing to take those loans because they though this was the way to go. No one can push anything on you unless you allow them to do so. As you said, they made a dumb choice and paid for it dearly. Lesson learned. Why should I hold the seller accountable for something you chose to buy? I simply don't get that. If I go to a grocery store and elect to buy a head of lettuce that is half rotted, it's not the store's fault that I purchased it. The fault is mine and mine alone. OK, I looked up who Lindsay Lohan is. Yep she's been in the news repeatedly for various issues, mostly centered on alcoholism. You don't think she is paying enough, I take it? I'm not here to defend her as I know next to nothing about her. I can tell you this. I've lived with a alcoholic and it is tragic. They pay a huge personal price for their addiction.

So are you telling me that corporations can't make huge profits? And what business is it of ours what a CEO makes? I may be envious, or think that they are over paid, but that decision is not mine to make. Moving jobs overseas is OUR doing, not the companies'. How badly do you want a job? Are you competitive for the work you do? I think the answer to that is a NO. Too many with run-of the mill skills feel they are worth a whole lot more than they really are. We demand top dollar for our services, even when a million others out there can do the same and are willing and happy to do it for less. The rest of the world validates that point. That is why jobs go overseas. You (rhetorical) want to buy things cheaply, but your wage and benefit demands will add too much to the price of the manufactured goods. Yes, it's a vicious circle, but it's still up to each and every individual to break the circle. What I hear from you and OSW is that it's impossible because the deck is stacked against us. I say BS to that. Nothing is impossible when you put your mind to making it possible.

Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.

16 Nov 2011 11:46 #37 by Soulshiner
I think that the OWS crowds have at least gotten everyone talking about this. Whether they have done it the right way or not, they have at least accomplished this

When you plant ice you're going to harvest wind. - Robert Hunter

Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.

16 Nov 2011 11:56 #38 by Rockdoc

chickaree wrote: The message I get from the OWS movement (disclosure: daughter and SIL are active participants AND employed) is that they object to a small percentage controlling the direction of our country-government and economy both. I can't argue with that. They are outraged that the very people who caused our economic crisis continue to benefit from it. I can't argue with that either. I also believe that if you want to make a difference you need to get out there and make it. For that reason I tend to admire everyone who actively protests whether I agree with their message or not.


I certainly don't debate that a small percentage controls the direction of our country-government and economy. Where I differ is that OSW supporter perceive they have no role in this. Aren't we the ones buying all the products and electing the officials to do political battle? It's not just them. And what does the protest hope to accomplish? If you are so powerless do you really believe, this will actually bring about significant change? Perhaps you do, I don't. I think the protests are akin to a fly on a horse's a**, an annoyance to be swated away with the swish of a tail. If you want to really deal with things, you will need to take an active stand and simply clean house. When realization dawns that the protest are flies and stronger measures are contemplated, then we will see some serius and lasting change. Then is when I will be there as well.

Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.

16 Nov 2011 11:57 #39 by chickaree

FredHayek wrote:

chickaree wrote: The message I get from the OWS movement (disclosure: daughter and SIL are active participants AND employed) is that they object to a small percentage controlling the direction of our country-government and economy both. I can't argue with that. They are outraged that the very people who caused our economic crisis continue to benefit from it. I can't argue with that either. I also believe that if you want to make a difference you need to get out there and make it. For that reason I tend to admire everyone who actively protests whether I agree with their message or not.


Like I have said before, I am sympathetic to the OWS crowd, but they really are doing it the wrong way. Hanging out in a park smoking dope and beating drums won't change anything. Run for political office, or work for the candidates you support. Working within the system will do a lot more good than pouting in your tents.

This is a very distorted image of what is going on. Just as the press hunted out neo-nazi types and signs like "keep your government away from my medicare" at TEA party rallies they also hunt out the dippy hippy types at these OWS protests.

Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.

16 Nov 2011 11:58 #40 by bailey bud
clarifying my thoughts ----

Magnifiers - the groups who tend to be critiquing someone other than ourselves.
(politicians, activists, columnists, commentators)

I think OWS and the Tea Party movement both fit into this group. Both tend to look for external problems. Oddly, both movements are inherently self-serving. The Tea Party would like to hold on to what they have --- while OWS feels entitled to something - even if they have nothing to offer.

Mirrors - the group that after (perhaps "through") critical self-reflection - does something to change their state of affairs.
(readers of Backwoods Home seem to fall into this category)

I'm kind of tired of the pointless and fruitless accusations, analysis, and advocacy seen with the extremes. The dysfunctional extremes are bound to lead to paralysis and inaction (might be a good thing!).

The red tie cult can go on babbling as much as they like - I'm moving closer each day to the mirror side of things. I've played around with the magnifier, and it doesn't really work for me.

Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.

Time to create page: 0.147 seconds
Powered by Kunena Forum
sponsors
© My Mountain Town (new)
Google+