Should certains Christmas Carols be banned from schools?

You, sir, are a liar.

major bean wrote: You, sir, are a liar.

Am I wrong? If so, I will admit it. Please cite your proof that I lied.

major bean wrote: I just read the short bio of Madalyn Murray O'Hair given at Wikipedia. Her life is a mirror of most liberals.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Madalyn_Murray_O'Hair

Here is the post where you injected O'Hair into the thread. Then your statement insinuated that liberals are atheists.

Scruffy wrote: It was you, not I, that deviated from the topic by trying to color liberals as atheists. Then when you were again caught backpedaling, you try to tell me that we are off topic?

Here is the quote where you lie.

And connecting O'Hair to the school/religion debate is not a digression from the topic of the thread.

I think that the pink hair says quite a lot about your preferences.

The school/religion debate is rooted in atheism from day one.

major bean wrote:

Scruffy wrote: It was you, not I, that deviated from the topic by trying to color liberals as atheists. Then when you were again caught backpedaling, you try to tell me that we are off topic?

Here is the quote where you lie.

And connecting O'Hair to the school/religion debate is not a digression from the topic of the thread.

I think that the pink hair says quite a lot about your preferences.

Can you point out where I lie? Where in that post did I lie - specifically? Just citing the statement where you claim I lie without backing it up is not very helpful.

major bean wrote: The school/religion debate is rooted in atheism from day one.

How so?

Are you that mentally slow?

It is very interesting that it was not I that brought up the atheist element into this thread. It was introduced by LJ and expanded upon by Pineguy and Scruffy.
Then Scruffy acuses me of introducing/connecting atheism and liberalism. It would appear to me that there were some liberal consciences that were stung by the mention of O'Hair.

Scruffy that is where you lied.

Scruffy wrote: Am I wrong? If so, I will admit it. Please cite your proof that I lied.

I am waiting. Surely you have integrety.